Framed or unframed, desk size to sofa size, printed by us in Arizona and Alabama since 2007. Explore now.
Shorpy is funded by you. Patreon contributors get an ad-free experience.
Learn more.
Buffalo, New York, circa 1904. "St. Paul's Cathedral, Episcopal." 8x10 inch dry plate glass negative, Detroit Publishing Company. View full size.
Below is the same view from September of 2022.
One explanantion of the vanishing man at the left, Mr. Scott just got the command to beam this guy up, and in seconds he should be safely aboard the starship Enterprise.
The lens vignette effect makes it look like a scene from some Twilight Zone episode where a 19th century American town has somehow been relocated to a moon of Jupiter.
Are those windows in the steeple? Is it possible to go up inside it? Whatever for?
According to the Historic American Buildings Survey, the cathedral's load-bearing masonry exterior walls and the 275-foot main spire are all made of red Medina sandstone that came from a church-owned quarry near Huddleston, N.Y. The rest of the roof is covered in slate shingles. The heavily buttressed main entrance and the spire survived a disastrous gas explosion and fire in 1888 that gutted the rest of the building and necessitated its reconstruction in 1888-1890.
Many photographers today are obsessed with technical qualities like centre-to-edge sharpness, vignetting and light falloff and will use only the most advanced lenses.
Here we have a photograph where the back has been shifted so far to that the lens no longer covers the entire plate and a lens that can't quite resolve the top of the steeple. By contemporary standards, this would be an unacceptable documentary photograph.
What I see here is a a photographer who worked with and within the technical limitations of his equipment to produce a very striking image. A lot of contemporary 'gearhead' photogs could learn from this.
The tall building at the left is Adler & Sullivan's Guaranty (aka Prudential) Building of 1894-1895, seen from the back. You can just make out the cornice at the top of the facade and the arch over the doorway, both shown in extreme foreshortening.
You have it exactly backwards, bub. How (and when) do you think the great cathedrals of Europe were built?
Notice the church's steeple is of brick. It boggles my mind when I try to figure out how men were able to lay the brick at that height and angle, considering the tools and equipment available during that era. Wow!
On Shorpy:
Today’s Top 5